Ticking sound on cold start - with video

[waybar17]

Hello

I've just bought my first M3 V8, which runs very well

However, on cold start, until the revs drop, it has a ticking sound, mainly from underneath or back of engine. The ticking stops about 5 seconds before the revs drop from 1,000rpm to 750rpm. It does not tick at any other point, and not in the 1600-2000 'dreaded bearing rev range'

It's done 52k mile, had the actuators done, and on the original bearings

I've taken it to a dealer who said it was normal and just the hydraulic valves filling with oil, which I don't believe, because the ticking continues until the cold start high revs drop

Any ideas whether this is an issue or normal and if anyone has had the same issue and resolved it

Its filled with TWS 10w60 oil less than 1,000 miles ago

Here's a Youtube link to a short video, demonstrating the ticking when at 1k rpm and then at 750rpm

thanks

[EMKOOP]

OP that sounds pretty normal (to my ears).

The lifters are doing their work.

[waybar17]

thanks - just the confirmation I needed from another owner

[Pauliecas]

Perfectly normal

[RocketyMan]

Originally Posted by waybar17

Hello

I've just bought my first M3 V8, which runs very well

However, on cold start, until the revs drop, it has a ticking sound, mainly from underneath or back of engine. The ticking stops about 5 seconds before the revs drop from 1,000rpm to 750rpm. It does not tick at any other point, and not in the 1600-2000 'dreaded bearing rev range'

It's done 52k mile, had the actuators done, and on the original bearings

I've taken it to a dealer who said it was normal and just the hydraulic valves filling with oil, which I don't believe, because the ticking continues until the cold start high revs drop

Any ideas whether this is an issue or normal and if anyone has had the same issue and resolved it

Its filled with TWS 10w60 oil less than 1,000 miles ago

Here's a Youtube link to a short video, demonstrating the ticking when at 1k rpm and then at 750rpm

thanks

That's completely normal. The engine runs through it's startup routine to try and heat the cats and O2s up the fastest. This is done in combination of timing, injection, VANOS, and SAI strategy. What you are hearing is just an artifact of that through the exhaust.

You can verify this on a cold engine start with data. And if you are able to graph it--that'd be pretty neat.

You'll also notice that if you idle for too long, the DME will actually raise the idle from 550 rpms to like 700ish. I bet this is when the cats start to cool down and/or the O2 readings It's kinda interesting to me.

I'm trying to search TIS on this...didn't find too specific of information, but there is a target "Diagnosis value" of the O2 sensors the DME targets.

[waybar17]

Thanks for the replies and confirmation from three other M3 owners

I hope this thread can put the mind of any other new M3 owners in the future at ease

[BrokeBarney]

First time s65 owner, put my car on the lift today to look for an exhaust leak. Turns out, its perfectly normal! Identical to your video.

Almost three years later, helping me sleep tonight for sure!

[Thumbie]

Originally Posted by waybar17

I hope this thread can put the mind of any other new M3 owners in the future at ease

Yes, and the many other threads all asking the same question.

S65 is a noisy bastard.

Yours sounds healthy.

If you get lifter tick that continues after cold start, there's a sure-fire way to remedy it: warm it up and drive it like it was meant to be driven

[omgzirra_exe]

just don't use liquid moly and your engine will be quieter.

[vlo41662523]

Needs an italian tune up , once at operating temp off course **

[inoizink]

Sounds healthy! Enjoy it!

[sergbaja5t]

Originally Posted by Thumbie

Yes, and the many other threads all asking the same question.

S65 is a noisy bastard.

Yours sounds healthy.

If you get lifter tick that continues after cold start, there's a sure-fire way to remedy it: warm it up and drive it like it was meant to be driven

What's funny is I thought the s65 was loud until owning a s58... holy crap the s58 sounds like a diesel, and s65 is sowing machine.