7.2KVIEWS
40REPLIES
0APPRECIATES
05-21-2008LAST POST
Keto wrote
The e46 M3 leather was Nappa (same as Napa? who knows) and the Novillo leather is markedly better in feel.
Really!! Wow, I honestly cannot tell the difference between the Nappa in my MB and my E92M3!! But hey, maybe MB uses Novillo and calls it Nappa, or my "feel" nerve is FU! :lol:
BMW-M-Mexico wrote
If by extended leather you mean all that plastic in another color, then I have seen many and don't like it. Its not really "extended leather".
lol, there's no plastic on the M3 in an other color than black. When you see a silver, red or beige lower dashboard, that's leather.


Best regards, south
southlight wrote
lol, there's no plastic on the M3 in another color than black. When you see a silver, red or beige lower dashboard, that's leather.


Best regards, south
Hahahahaha!!!! Thanks for the clarification South, it looks like plastic in the pics. BIG mistake!! Then I think it must be really nice.
Guys

Having sat in both, the extended leather is really worth it. The additional leather really adds to the "premium" feel of the car and helps to distinguish it from the otherwise regular 3er interior, one thing that most reviewers have remarked on as being disappointing.

That said, if I had my heart set on black leather, I might not bother. FR, PS & BB definitely.

Mick
BMW-M-Mexico wrote
Hahahahaha!!!! Thanks for the clarification South, it looks like plastic in the pics. BIG mistake!! Then I think it must be really nice.
You have been around the board long enough you should know. This is very surprising.
http://www.m3post.com/forums/bpgarage.php?do=view&id=2773

Click on my interior pic image. Color aside, the leather on the seats flow right into the the console, dash, and doors. It's all personal preference, but I do like the look.

Is it worth 1.1K? That's the question.
IMHO, it's not worth the cost. I got nearly every other option, so I'm glad I saved some money somewhere. I also didn't get the the Sirius radio, so I guess I saved money there too.
Epacy wrote
You have been around the board long enough you should know. This is very surprising.
Yes I should!! Oh well, goes to show!!!
Epacy wrote
Captain Obvious, I think the fact we were talking about M3s was very apparent.
Maybe I read too many forums, but it didn't come across that way to me, especially when you mentioned all those threads. :confused2
BMW-M-Mexico wrote
I have a MB with Napa and it feels, smells and looks identical to Novillo. Also, one guy building a steering wheel that works with leather told me its the same thing, although several people here believe it is somehow different (and they may be right). I just can't tell the difference.
Is Napa (Nappa?) the same thing in MB as in BMW? I'm not really sure what makes leather Nappa, Novillo, Merino, Oregon, etc. I've asked but never seen a good answer to this. Only stuff like "Merino > Nappa". Do the different leathers come from different animals? Is it treated differently? Is one softer or longer lasting? And is there a standard, i.e. does it mean the same thing to different manufacturers? I wish I knew the answers.
ersin wrote
Is Napa (Nappa?) the same thing in MB as in BMW? I'm not really sure what makes leather Nappa, Novillo, Merino, Oregon, etc. I've asked but never seen a good answer to this. Only stuff like "Merino > Nappa". Do the different leathers come from different animals? Is it treated differently? Is one softer or longer lasting? And is there a standard, i.e. does it mean the same thing to different manufacturers? I wish I knew the answers.
All good questions indeed!!! The difference that I can see in Mercedes-AMG Nappa and my M3 Novillo (which means calf in Italian) to other leathers is that they are really much smoother, have no imperfections or wrinkles, smell better and feel much softer and supple (again, I own and MB AMG and the M3 and cannot tell the difference between these). I should say however that I can immediately tell the difference between these leathers and other “less expensive” MB or BMW models. If there is a difference between Mercedes-AMG Nappa and BMW M Novillo leather, I cannot for the life of me discern the differences!!! So, I do think what that leather guy told me is probably correct, that they are in fact the same. I have not stepped into an E46 in at least three years so I don´t know if their “Nappa” is the same and Mercedes-AMG; from the above statements, I suspect not.
Didn't get it. Money wasn't the reason. I would have selected the option if I'd chosen another interior color, but Fox Red didn't look that great to me in extended. Just too much red.
JasonSucksBalls wrote
Does it have leather on the dash?
No, it doesn't. It has leather on the bottom of the dash, up to knee level, and then stops. Porsche extended leather wraps the whole dashboard and looks intense. I don't like BMW's mini-extended leather.

TheBry wrote
Didn't get it. Money wasn't the reason. I would have selected the option if I'd chosen another interior color, but Fox Red didn't look that great to me in extended. Just too much red.
I agree completely. The Fox Red needs some more black to balance out the interior. Because BMW half-assed the extended leather, I went with FR.

If they had really done extended like Porsche, I would've gone for the black as a FULL black leather interior is beautiful. If they offered deviating stitching color like Porsche, ... :drool: I feel like the extended leather is a "nice try, but not quite there" on these cars. I'd rather have the regular dash than have someone ask me why I didn't get the option "to have the top covered too." The E46 Individual dash was available completely wrapped in leather so I'm kind of disappointed that BMW didn't carry that forward. Just my opinion.
Epacy wrote
You have been around the board long enough you should know. This is very surprising.
Nothing I see on here surprises me anymore.
ersin wrote
To clarify -- all M3s. In the other 3-series it's wood or aluminum.
We're not talking about the interior trim strips. :lol:
I have ordered my M3 with Extended Fox Red Leather. I think It completes the Interior Better.
Without Extended Leather, IMHO the interior looks Half done.
I had Imola Red Interior in my E46 M3 and I wish BMW had the Extended Leather Option
available when I was Ordering my Car (e46 M3). It would have look 10x's Better.
What I would really wish BMW Did was Really make the Extended Really "Extended"
by wrapping the dash too like the P cars with color stitching. I dont know why
they still half assed it. Anyways, I still think the extended still completes the
interior better then without it....
mofomat wrote
Nothing I see on here surprises me anymore.
Vaild...
Epacy wrote
Captain Obvious, I think the fact we were talking about M3s was very apparent.
Actually I was speaking to those coming from non-M cars like myself..my last was a 330i and I do prefer the black leather in the M of course. I just mentioned it because someone had said something about plastic and the fact that new M owners may not realize that center console was black leather, I had no idea and was happy to see it.
i think Novillo feels softer than Nappa leather. when i sat in the E92 M3, it feels softer than the E46 M3.