|
|
12-17-2018, 11:18 PM | #1 |
Captain
865
Rep 765
Posts |
Secondary cat delete pros and cons
Hello everyone,
Disclaimer - this is a long “question”. Please don’t judge, but also answer wholeheartedly. Thank you. I just recently picked up a Borla ATAK that I got for a hell of deal - $750 and the thing looked barely used. So, I feel like I can justify some extra funds going to the exhaust portion of my winter project list, and I want to get the opinions of others who know more than I do. Plus, my local opinions have been divided, so I thought I would ask on the forum. First off - I know Borla is not everyone’s favorite on here, but I love the sound of this exhaust so I was pretty damn stoked to find what I wanted for such a good price. Really my only issue is with the tips, which I am changing out soon anyways. My local exhaust guy said he has a whole catalog of custom tips I can choose from, so that should be fun. But, I am now wondering if there is anything else I should have done while the car is at the exhaust shop. I only wonder because one of my buddies who was at the shop while we installed the ATAK suggested I remove the secondary cats (while keeping the resonators I assume?). His line of reasoning was that they were not really necessary and that the overall sound would be just a little bit louder if I removed them. I also had a couple other friends suggest removing the secondary cats with this exhaust as well. So, now I have some questions. Below is what I need help with, thank you in advance for any insight. I’m sorry if some of these questions are stupid. I am learning about all of this as I go and I am having a hard time finding solid advice/info online for my specific questions and situation, so I was hoping someone with some direct knowledge might chime it. Just for the record, I would be happy if it was just a tad louder… which is why I am considering this. 1. Will removing the secondary cats change the tone of the exhaust sound that is produced by my ATAK? Or, will it simply just be louder? Or, is there even any way to tell without just doing it? I am really happy with the tone right now, so I am nervous to start messing around with the remaining stock parts of my exhaust without having a good idea of what I am getting myself into. 2. Will my engine performance be affected at all by removing the secondary cats? If so, how? Air/fuel mixture? Would it cause a CEL? I don’t want to do anything that upsets the balance of my engine simply for more noise, even though I like (relatively) loud. 3. The state of SC does not require emissions testing so I am not worried about whether or not I would be able to pass emissions tests… now. But, who knows what the future holds with these types of things. If I remove the secondary cats, would there be issues with passing emissions tests? (I am pretty sure the answer to this is yes) Thank you for any and all opinions/advice |
12-18-2018, 08:47 AM | #2 |
Captain
223
Rep 979
Posts |
Have you removed the primary cats? If not that’s the ones I would remove first...
Cat removal will change the tone, volume and smell. If you going to go catless just buy an aftermarket x pipe.
__________________
2011 E92 M3 | JEREZ BLACK | EXTENDED BAMBOO NOVILLO | EXECUTIVE PKG | M-DRIVE | EDC | M-DCT
MODS | KW S/O | HRE P40SC | Akra Evo |ESS Akra Tune | ESS DCT tune | BMC drop in | StopTech Trophies | TMS Pulley | LUX V3 | BE Bearings and BE ARP rod bolts |
Appreciate
2
DreamTime864.50 Powashiftin170.50 |
12-18-2018, 09:02 AM | #3 |
Brigadier General
2383
Rep 3,726
Posts
Drives: 2018 M2
Join Date: Mar 2014
Location: Boston, MA
|
I think you might want to consider test pipes which will turn your setup into a high flow cat setup. You’ll gain the volume you want and still leave the resonators in place
Hi btw lol |
Appreciate
1
DreamTime864.50 |
12-18-2018, 09:22 AM | #4 |
Lieutenant Colonel
4100
Rep 1,612
Posts |
I've always had test pipes , stock xpipe, Megan rear
Once I removed the secondary cats... I can't even drive with my windows down, or if I i back into the garage and get out my cloths smell so bad when I go in the house lol So just take the smell into account , cuz it's pretty dang bad lol |
Appreciate
1
DreamTime864.50 |
12-18-2018, 11:19 PM | #5 | |||
Captain
865
Rep 765
Posts |
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Thanks guys, it looks like the short answer is - don't remove secondary cats. I'm just going to switch out my tips for now and focus on the rest of my huge winter project list. I am happy with the sound of my exhaust right now, so later on I will check out some other fun options. |
|||
Appreciate
0
|
12-18-2018, 11:50 PM | #6 |
BimmerPost Supporting Vendor
3387
Rep 7,541
Posts |
Removing the secondary cats will not provide much of a performance difference, but will significantly increase the raspyness from our experience.
__________________
-----| Like us on Facebook | Instagram || Tuning Information | Remote Coding |----- ----Visit us at www.BPMSport.com - Emotion. Driven. | Toll Free: (888) 557-5133---- |
Appreciate
3
|
12-19-2018, 05:33 AM | #7 | |
Captain
223
Rep 979
Posts |
Quote:
The power comes from removal of the primary cats and not the seconardary ones which is the big reason why people remove the cats in the first place. If you are not on a quest for more power then your fine with the stock xpipe
__________________
2011 E92 M3 | JEREZ BLACK | EXTENDED BAMBOO NOVILLO | EXECUTIVE PKG | M-DRIVE | EDC | M-DCT
MODS | KW S/O | HRE P40SC | Akra Evo |ESS Akra Tune | ESS DCT tune | BMC drop in | StopTech Trophies | TMS Pulley | LUX V3 | BE Bearings and BE ARP rod bolts |
|
Appreciate
1
DreamTime864.50 |
12-19-2018, 06:19 AM | #8 |
Captain
420
Rep 656
Posts |
1) As bpmsport said above.
2)No cel. Your car has no way to know if the secondary cats are there. The car only monitors the primary cats. 3) No issue passing emmissions due to secondary cat removal as stated above. No cel. My personal experience with borla atak is that I loved the sound with stock xpipe. Once I went to an aftermarket xpipe that even is quad resonated the borla atak became too loud. I suspect simply removing secondary OR primary cats only will be a perfect setup for that rear section. I wanted to keep the catless xpipe since I am SC'D so I changed rear section. |
Appreciate
1
DreamTime864.50 |
12-19-2018, 04:22 PM | #10 | |
Lieutenant
244
Rep 433
Posts |
Quote:
1) HFC in the secondary position and dual resonated like Evolve or 2) Quad resonated and fully catless like Dinan or Borla |
|
Appreciate
0
|
12-19-2018, 05:55 PM | #11 |
Private
40
Rep 65
Posts |
I have the ATAK on my car, and initially it was just the rear section. Like you, I hoped it would have had a bit more volume. I’m also not a fan of the tips, though seeing how they’re angled it doesn’t look all that trivial to replace them, but maybe it isn’t a big deal for an exhaust shop.
I later added AA test pipes and kept the stock X, and I was pretty shocked at how much the sound changed. Volume increase was substantial enough that I had to get back under the car to see if I had messed up something like leaking exhaust before the mufflers. The tone itself I would say became more raw sounding rather than the hint of exotic refined sound prior, but I don’t think I could go back, it just sounds so mean now. The volume is perfect now as a non-DD, and it’s true that the test pipes reduce drone. |
Appreciate
1
DreamTime864.50 |
12-19-2018, 06:12 PM | #12 | ||||
Captain
865
Rep 765
Posts |
Thanks everyone, there is some good stuff in here.
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Also, thanks for the feedback on personal experience with the ATAK and different x pipe configurations. Your comment on removing one of the sets of cats is interesting to me. Do you feel that is true because the sound level would be about right if only primary or secondary cats were removed? I am hesitant to remove my primary cats because (although I do modify the car a good bit) I truthfully want to keep the engine performance output at stock levels for longevity's sake. Not sure if this is warranted, but it makes me feel better. Car now has 120k miles on it, will be retired from the track soon, and starting next winter I will start replacing all engine, transmission/clutch, and suspension wear items that have not already been replaced. I want to keep the car running and happy for many many miles Quote:
I had a feeling something like this might be a valid solution from the get go lol. I feel like if I would choose to remove cats, that I should just go with something aftermarket instead of cutting apart my stock exhaust. |
||||
Appreciate
0
|
12-19-2018, 06:19 PM | #13 | |
Brigadier General
2383
Rep 3,726
Posts
Drives: 2018 M2
Join Date: Mar 2014
Location: Boston, MA
|
Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
1
DreamTime864.50 |
12-19-2018, 06:24 PM | #14 | |
Captain
865
Rep 765
Posts |
Quote:
Oh.. this is very interesting feedback about your current setup though. It sounds exactly like the sound I want produced, although it's hard to tell without hearing it. I have an exhaust newbie question - please don't judge lol... which part of the exhaust is removed/replaced by the test pipes? Are either of the cats removed? |
|
Appreciate
0
|
12-19-2018, 06:27 PM | #15 |
Captain
865
Rep 765
Posts |
I'm gonna text you tomorrow... I do have questions. But, I must pull myself out of car mod land for now and go finish my Christmas shopping before it gets any later lmao
|
Appreciate
0
|
12-19-2018, 10:38 PM | #17 | |
Private
40
Rep 65
Posts |
Quote:
http://images.activeautowerke.com/Installation%20PDF's/AA%20E9x%20M3%20%20TSP%20-%20Test%20Pipe%20Exhaust%20instructions.pdf |
|
Appreciate
1
DreamTime864.50 |
12-20-2018, 11:40 PM | #19 | |
Captain
865
Rep 765
Posts |
Quote:
I have recently become very interested in my exhaust system as a whole and all of the options that are out there to modify it. It is so interesting to me. It is such a basic part of the car, but there are a lot of mod options that I know little to nothing about, and I have limited spare time right now for hours of researching. Your answer is very much appreciated!! If only I could double appreciate a post lol |
|
Appreciate
0
|
12-20-2018, 11:48 PM | #20 | |
Captain
865
Rep 765
Posts |
Quote:
One of the first things I did to my car when I got it was the OEM exhaust mod, but I have been longing for something louder... hence the atak. I hadn't considered secondary cat delete with my OEM exhaust mod. Your combo is a winner, sounds amazing! |
|
Appreciate
0
|
12-25-2018, 06:34 PM | #21 |
Major General
1571
Rep 8,076
Posts
Drives: 11 E90 M3 Individual
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Houston, TX
|
This is a good video. The first half is an modified OEM exhaust and a straight thru X-pipe. Its really loud just in the video. Not even mentioning when they put the straight pipes in place of the modded OEM exhaust.
I'd delete the primary cats and modify the OEM rear exhaust to get more exhaust noise. Especially if you have a DCT because its hard to hear the motor going over 100mph with the windows down and helmet on. The S65 induction noise sounds too good to drown it out with exhaust noise. Unlike the S54 which sounds like garbage. So I just go for lots of hot, loud garbage so you can't even tell it sounds bad.
__________________
2018 F30 320iX Melbourne Red
2011 E90 M3 Monte Carlo Blue 2004 E46 M3 Imola Red 2000 E36/7 Z3 Steel Blue |
Appreciate
1
Makaveli7116.50 |
12-26-2018, 09:55 PM | #22 | |
Captain
865
Rep 765
Posts |
Quote:
I have a friend who had a straight piped E92 M3 and it was ridiculously loud. Definitely more than what I am looking for right now lol. To be completely honest, I am really happy with the current setup. I think you are absolutely right - the beautiful music of the S65 is too perfect to drown out simply with loud ass exhaust noise. I had the OEM exhaust mod and it was not quite loud enough, but the ATAK muffler gives me the best of both worlds. I have my lovely exhaust note but I can still hear the sound of my engine while driving. I guess my main question was whether or not it was wise to delete secondary cats for a slightly louder exhaust with the ATAK. Based off of the answers I have determined removing the secondary cats is not something I am going to do. Great advice in here though, I appreciate the feedback! Hope you had a great Christmas!! I can already hardly wait for next track season |
|
Appreciate
1
Makaveli7116.50 |
Post Reply |
Bookmarks |
|
|