|
|
12-20-2018, 01:07 AM | #1 |
BimmerPost Supporting Vendor
1452
Rep 1,614
Posts |
Building your own flat-plane "P65" engine
Building your own flat-plane "P65" engine
Introduction: It's time to unveil a project we've mentioned here and there, but haven't been ready to talk about. We wanted it to get far enough along to ensure it would become a reality. Background: Almost all V8's produced are built in a "cross-plane" configuration. A cross-plane crank positions the rod journals every 90-degrees. Because of the 90-degree positions, large counterweights are required to balance the crankshaft. A cross-plane runs very smooth and is easy to manufacture. Most importantly, cross-plane engines are very reliable and have that throaty V8 sound everybody knows and loves. What is a flat-plane crank? A flat plane crank is different. Instead of rod journals positioned every 90-degrees, a flat-plane crank positions the rod journals every 180-degrees. The flat-plane crank can come in different configurations, but the most common is Up-Down-Down-Up -- exactly like two banks of 4-cylinder engines. The flat-plane crank has smaller counter weights, so it is much lighter. Lighter means it revs higher too. Higher revs typically means more power. If you've ever driven next to a Ferrari and noticed it sounds totally different than any other engine you've ever heard, most likely you've been listening to a flat-plane crank engine. Besides Ferrari, the Shelby Mustang GT350 and GT350R use a plat-plane crank. That's how rare it is to find a flat-plane crank in a production car. There are downsides to a flat-plane crank; the biggest is vibrations. Even though it's inherently balanced, engine builders like to say a flat-plane engine wants to saw itself in half. So now you go back to slightly larger counterweights, and very precise balancing to fix it. Another concern is the V8 configuration. V8's typically come in 90-degrees. But some V8's are configured as 45, 60, and 72-degrees. Because the flat-plane crankshaft has it's rod centers every 180-degrees, only a 90-degree V8 can be converted to a flat-plane engine. The S65 is a 90-degree V8. Here's a short video that visually shows the difference between a cross-plane and flat-plane crankshaft. Building your own flat-plane engine There are many obstacles to building a flat-plane engine. Assuming you can get a custom made flat-plane crank, you still need to get the camshafts to match. You can't use factory camshafts built for a cross-plane crank because the firing order is very different and assumed to be every 90-degrees. On the S65, this presents a very big problem: where do you get the flat-plane cams? It's not like you can call up your local BMW performance shop and order them. These cams must be custom made, or made by somebody who has S65 cam blanks and can make them with 180-degree firing order. But suppose you can get the crank and cams, you might need to change the valve train components too: cam followers, valve springs, maybe even need to change the valves (depending on which cam followers you choose). If you're going to this much of an expense to build a flat-plane engine, it's doubtful you'll want to use the heavier hydraulic lifters in the factory S65. Most likely you'll want to change the lifters to mechanical with a radius cup (radius cup reduces wear). That's when it gets interesting. Whatever cams you make, they must match the valve train. You can't buy cams for mechanical lifters with radius cups and use them either on hydraulic lifters or lifters with a flat cup. The cams and cam followers must be thought out and built to match each other. Since the flat-plane engine has a different firing order, you'll need to solve that problem too. There's three ways to solve it: 1) rewire the harness to change the order of the coils and injectors; 2) convince the MSS60 to change the firing order; 3) use a standalone ECU. All three of these are pretty straight forward. Now that you've decided to move forward, it's time to order the parts. How this project got started: This project is Bert's: Bert @ BEBearings. We (Auto Talent) work with Bert and help him with parts, and occasionally lend him our engine builder. Bert started this project over a year ago, but I think he got the idea long before that. Bert also works with Dinan for machine shop work, and knew they had shut down their P65 race engine program. The P65 is BMW's flat-plane S65 racing engine. I asked Bert why he wanted to do this, and he said: "because nobody's done it before." Some time in 2016 Bert was at Dinan taking care of Sergei's S65 engine dyno when he asked if he could photograph the flat plane crank. Fast forward a year or so, and Bert was back at Dinan to pick up a machined block when he asked Dinan if they had any spare P65 parts they'd be willing to sell. Specifically he needed the cams because that's the part Bert couldn't get made by himself. Surprisingly, a deal was made that day to buy an 83mm flat-plane crank and full set of cams at a very reasonable price. Bert walked out happy. P65 in 2018/2019 Worried that the 83mm crank was too much stroke, Bert wanted to have a new crank made at 81mm. Bert contacted Van Dyne Engineering and had them order an 81mm flat-plane crank, a set of rods, and set of pistons. With Van Dyne's advice, Bert decided that the crankshaft would not be designed to use a BMW rod journal. Instead this design uses a smaller and well know racing journal that has many different sizes of over/under sized bearings available. This approach solves three problems: it lightens the rotating mass of the crankshaft, adds a little more surface area because the bearings are wider, and allows Van Dyne to dial in the clearance to anything they want. Clevite offered to donate the bearings for the project. The Carrillo connecting rods were made to match the race journal size crankshaft. Due to the smaller rod big-end, the connecting rods are noticeably lighter than a standard Carrillo S65 connecting rod. The pistons were made by CP-Carrillo using the PD-14 coating to make it compatible with the BMW Alucil block. The pistons are 93mm bore. Total displacement is 4402 CC's. Solving the valve train issue: Since these Schrick cams were already made for the P65 race engine, the specs were unknown. We had no idea of the lift, duration, and whether they required hydraulic lifters versus mechanical lifters or required a radius cup versus flat cup. After multiple emails back and forth with Schrick, the specs were given as follows: 12.6mm lift, 292-degrees duration, mechanical lifters, radius cup. Schrick provided the firing order with the specs of the cams (very helpful). Those are great specs, but they present big problems. The cam followers ("lifters") Dinan used were supplied by BMW Motorsport, manufactured by Del West, and measure 32mm diameter. The factory hydraulic lifters are 28mm diameter. So either we need to machine the head for the 32mm cam followers, have a batch of cam followers custom made, or figure out another solution. Dinan insisted the factory S65 head and racing P65 heads, though 95% identical, are not compatible to machine the cam follower bores to 32mm. Bert remained skeptical, but without a full set of the 32mm Del West followers, it was a moot point. (Dinan provided one sample as a loaner.) Bert contacted various manufacturers who make cam followers, and was told they could make anything except a radius cup. Luckily a solution presented itself to "do something else" -- but we're not saying what it is. All we can say is that it's a rock solid proven solution and guaranteed to work. It's even rather inexpensive. Del West Cam followers Using this "rock solid" solution also means we can keep the factory valves. If we had custom made cam followers, almost surely we would also have to replace the valves with longer tip valves. The lucky solution allows us to keep the factory valves, save the money, and use the Schrick racing valve springs to match the cams. The block and final bits and pieces: Once the pistons arrived, the block was sent to Dinan for bore/hone. The block was returned and ready for use. The only remaining delay was for the crankshaft to finish being manufactured. The crankshaft took 6-months to make, and cost about 20% more than a typical stroker crankshaft. The crankshaft was completed early December 2018 and immediately picked up. Bert drove down to Van Dyne to inspect it, shoot some photos, and get ready for the build. Everything is in place. The block is bored; the crankshaft, rods, pistons are all made. Cams are ready and the valve train is not an issue. The engine is ready to assemble. The build will start in early 2019. Best news of all: Probably the best news of all is Schrick is willing to make more of these cams (if you know what they are and how to order them). These are not cams found on the shelf, and you cannot call Schick and ask them to make you a set. Through his contacts with Schrick, they promised to make Bert more cams if he wants. Bert already has two people lined up, asking for a flat-plane S65 of their own. The 83mm flat-plane crank Bert didn't use, is already sold and should be appearing sometime later in it's own P65 project. Pictures: (click the pictures to enlarge) Full Photo Album: http://www.rcollins-home.org/photobu....php?album=279 Flat-Plane Crankshaft Connecting Rods Pistons Camshafts All Together Now What does a flat-plane S65 sound like? Enjoy! Last edited by Green-Eggs; 12-20-2018 at 01:18 AM.. |
Appreciate
22
e92zero215.00 Aktavate247.50 ///M Power-Belgium68541.00 EnVe461042.00 tdott4036.00 DrFerry6748.00 Makaveli7116.50 Longboarder3478.50 redpriest2176.50 Ximian2067.00 CSBM52845.50 steven_s51.00 Silverstoneorspacegray113.50 take1step100.50 dparm3857.50 Law6417.00 chief208.00 mgmarsh39255.00 Remonster826.50 Assimilator1615.50 M3E90sedan119.50 Exclusivs555.50 |
12-20-2018, 01:18 AM | #2 |
Lieutenant Colonel
4116
Rep 1,635
Posts |
The main question , we ALL have....
Which rod bearings are best for this Wpc,vac,or BE. Lmao Jk Nice work |
Appreciate
13
abren247.50 Green-Eggs1452.00 nholmes543.00 M3ANMACHINE936.00 K-M391.50 Bimmer Barney1261.50 Whyte Dynamyte32.00 shu589200159.50 Three Pedal Steve891.50 Pappas Fritas63.00 slcook541865.00 Exclusivs555.50 tigermack494.00 |
12-20-2018, 02:50 AM | #3 |
Second Lieutenant
248
Rep 271
Posts
Drives: Red
Join Date: May 2017
Location: Reno / SFBA
|
Very cool project, cant wait to hear/see this thing running!
|
Appreciate
1
Green-Eggs1452.00 |
12-20-2018, 03:21 AM | #4 |
B.E.
451
Rep 761
Posts |
Wow
__________________
Current: 2022 TRX & 2010 GT3RS
Past: 2016 M3 Individual Grigio Telesto Pearl, Sakhir Orange/Black Full Leather w/ CF trim, 6MT, ZCP, CCB, etc... Previous: 2011 E92 M3 Melbourne Red on Black 6MT ZCP. --> now 2010 dedicated track car |
Appreciate
1
Green-Eggs1452.00 |
12-20-2018, 06:31 AM | #5 |
Major
434
Rep 1,286
Posts |
Super cool project. Are you taking the opportunity to use different sized crank main bearing journals rather than BMW spec?
What's the approach for the exhaust headers and how will you optimize those? |
Appreciate
0
|
12-20-2018, 07:16 AM | #7 |
BimmerPost Supporting Vendor
3946
Rep 2,964
Posts
Drives: 2011 E93 M3
Join Date: Nov 2014
Location: DFW, Texas
|
Thanks for posting it and not keeping this a secret. Have wanted to do this for a while, glad to see someone bringing it to life!
Strokers? Meh... Flat plane builds are the new cool. |
Appreciate
5
|
12-20-2018, 07:17 AM | #8 |
Major
1042
Rep 1,216
Posts |
What a project! Tuned in for more
__________________
2011.5 E90 M3
LeMans Blue |
Appreciate
1
Green-Eggs1452.00 |
12-20-2018, 07:19 AM | #9 |
Lieutenant
378
Rep 413
Posts |
|
Appreciate
5
|
12-20-2018, 07:33 AM | #10 |
Enthusiast
117
Rep 150
Posts |
what a project! so happy to hear that schrick is accepting to do these in the future!
Sorry if this sounds incorrect but would the flat crank setup freeze the Vanos in 1 place now ? and would the 4.4 and flat crank use a vibration damper? |
Appreciate
0
|
12-20-2018, 07:35 AM | #11 |
Brigadier General
4036
Rep 4,064
Posts |
Amazing.
__________________
|
Appreciate
1
Green-Eggs1452.00 |
12-20-2018, 12:39 PM | #12 |
///M Powered for Life
11736
Rep 10,457
Posts |
This is killing me!! Do it already!!!
Thank you Bert for always pushing the envelope of BMW M engines! |
Appreciate
1
Green-Eggs1452.00 |
12-20-2018, 02:28 PM | #13 |
Major General
3232
Rep 6,217
Posts |
///F3RRARI lol
__________________
|
Appreciate
0
|
12-20-2018, 02:37 PM | #14 |
Major General
2768
Rep 5,483
Posts |
I have a raging pulsating nerd-on
__________________
|
Appreciate
7
SAMM3Y3089.50 admranger3129.00 Green-Eggs1452.00 Scharbag2694.00 M3ANMACHINE936.00 bigjae19761606.50 Assimilator1615.50 |
12-20-2018, 06:18 PM | #15 |
Lieutenant
325
Rep 489
Posts
Drives: 2011 E90 M3 6MT
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Middletown, MD
|
I asked RRT about building me a flat plane engine. I can’t believe this is happening. Timing for me is awful but would buy in another life.
Curious what you will use to run the engine. Can you revise the stock engine computer? |
Appreciate
0
|
12-20-2018, 06:23 PM | #16 |
First Lieutenant
389
Rep 369
Posts |
Honestly, if you're going to go all out and build a flat plane engine, you might as well run a standalone engine management system that doesn't hold you back in certain aspects.
__________________
2018 Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio
2008 BMW M3 Sedan |
Appreciate
0
|
12-20-2018, 06:36 PM | #17 |
Lieutenant General
11649
Rep 12,757
Posts |
Pardon my ignorance, but if you aren't stroking it, what is the benefit? (Besides being cool)
__________________
Instagram; @roastbeefmike
|
Appreciate
1
Silverstoneorspacegray113.50 |
12-20-2018, 07:11 PM | #18 |
Brigadier General
1475
Rep 3,040
Posts |
This is amazing, way better than supercharger kits!
__________________
INSTAGRAM: GORDON.M3
North American Mr12Volt Carplay/Android Auto Distributor DINAN | EVOSPORT | VAC | ARP | RD SPORT | NEEZ | EIBACH | CSF | IND | BILSTEIN | KLASSEN | BREMBO | ENDLESS | BBS | BPM SPORT | PROJECT MU | EVENTURI |
Appreciate
1
Green-Eggs1452.00 |
12-20-2018, 07:14 PM | #19 |
Brigadier General
4094
Rep 4,336
Posts |
|
Appreciate
0
|
12-20-2018, 09:32 PM | #21 |
Derbo Tuning
3657
Rep 3,049
Posts |
oh this is going to be good.
__________________
IG:ruhrohz_m3
Journal: Link E9x ZCP Suspension Info: Link Track Chat Discord: https://discord.gg/VsKbTyqBVj |
Appreciate
2
Green-Eggs1452.00 ItsGary1457.00 |
12-20-2018, 09:44 PM | #22 |
Lieutenant
325
Rep 489
Posts
Drives: 2011 E90 M3 6MT
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Middletown, MD
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
Post Reply |
Bookmarks |
|
|