|
|
03-24-2011, 11:50 AM | #1 |
Major
213
Rep 1,395
Posts |
EDRs and admissibility
Event Data Recorders. I found a thread on this subject here, but it is in a location of the forum that gets little traffic. Please share your thoughts here.
In short my question is whether law enforcement or insurance adjusters can obtain the information and use it against you in an accident and to what degree and level of information the recorder provides. I understand dealers use this in engine repair scenarios to ensure you weren't revving too high, etc... Thanks.
__________________
Club 6MT 2008 E92 M3 6MT, AW/Blk Ext., brushed aluminum 2006 E46 M3 ZCP 6MT Carbon blk/blk(sold) 2001 E46 325Xi 5MT Jet Blk/Blk (sold) Last edited by Seattle S65B40; 03-24-2011 at 01:11 PM.. Reason: clarity |
03-24-2011, 12:14 PM | #2 |
Moderator
7512
Rep 19,368
Posts |
|
Appreciate
0
|
03-24-2011, 01:10 PM | #3 |
Major
213
Rep 1,395
Posts |
Thank you, sir. The car is surely equipped with it, but I'm not yet sure on the level of data it provides and whether this is admissible in a criminal or civil litigation context.
Is it even obtainable by anyone other than BMW? I have seen cases, albeit on a GM truck, where, following a serious collision, the insurance adjuster downloaded data from before the accident. He determined the insured was going the speed limit the entire time before the accident. Obviously, there can be other situations where it doesn't quite work to the vehicle operator's benefit. It would be nice to know exactly what data is recorded and whether that is available to anyone other than BMW.
__________________
Club 6MT 2008 E92 M3 6MT, AW/Blk Ext., brushed aluminum 2006 E46 M3 ZCP 6MT Carbon blk/blk(sold) 2001 E46 325Xi 5MT Jet Blk/Blk (sold) |
Appreciate
0
|
03-24-2011, 02:05 PM | #4 |
Brigadier General
478
Rep 3,044
Posts
Drives: 2011 Dakar Yellow M3, 2018 M5
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Orange County, California
|
The real q here is what were you doing before your accident that has you so worried?
__________________
[ESS VT2-625] [Akrapovic Evolution Exhaust] [KW Clubsports] [OSS Angel Eyes] [Revinora r-CRT Lip] [Vorsteiner Boot] [Challenge Race Diffuser] [See the Build Thread HERE] |
Appreciate
0
|
03-24-2011, 02:27 PM | #5 |
Major
213
Rep 1,395
Posts |
Thankfully, no accident here. I do "speed" in the sense that I do not travel the the precise speed limit at all material times. Just curious whether that data could ever harm my interests (or anyone else on here), or is it simply dealerships that are getting this data from our cars.
__________________
Club 6MT 2008 E92 M3 6MT, AW/Blk Ext., brushed aluminum 2006 E46 M3 ZCP 6MT Carbon blk/blk(sold) 2001 E46 325Xi 5MT Jet Blk/Blk (sold) |
Appreciate
0
|
03-24-2011, 02:31 PM | #6 |
Major
1020
Rep 1,486
Posts
Drives: 2012 e92 M3 DCT ZCP
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: Michigan
|
I'd imagine it couldn't be used against you for moving violations (other than a fine)for the simple fact it wouldn't indicated who was actually driving the car. For accident issues..?
|
Appreciate
0
|
03-24-2011, 02:33 PM | #7 |
Major General
258
Rep 5,012
Posts |
BMW would have to produce it by court order, so it'd only come into play in case of a very serious accident IMO. Otherwise it'd only be used by BMW to vindicate themselves in case of a bogus claim like 'unintended acceleration'. Or to deny a warranty claim due to a mechanical overrev (6MTs only), or something like that. By the way, I think it's only permissible to record the last 5 seconds, if I'm not mistaken, but who knows. Good day.
|
Appreciate
0
|
03-24-2011, 02:56 PM | #8 | |
Major
213
Rep 1,395
Posts |
Quote:
I agree, that only it would only be an issue in serious accidents. The adjuster example I cited above included a fatality. The problem is that the plaintiff's bar is really empowering attorneys to push for this kind of evidence in other accidents, and i wonder whether they will succeed in their efforts at getting this kind of evidence from BMWs. A 12 year old could get this info from a GM or Ford vehicle. I highly doubt your local, state or federal officers have the capability of getting this info at the scene from a car like the M3, but that may change. Btw, I think BMW would not be involved most likely. I think this info would be obtainable under Rule 34, in which case you would need a protective order to avoid giving it up, and I don't see a judge granting such an order. It's completely relevant to causation and there is no competing interest to weigh in favor of exclusion... No matter how you slice it, I see this as something that will only be expanded in the future. Federal legislation calling for similar and even more detailed data on all cars and having it be admissible in all criminal and civil actions is not out of the question.
__________________
Club 6MT 2008 E92 M3 6MT, AW/Blk Ext., brushed aluminum 2006 E46 M3 ZCP 6MT Carbon blk/blk(sold) 2001 E46 325Xi 5MT Jet Blk/Blk (sold) |
|
Appreciate
0
|
03-24-2011, 03:11 PM | #10 |
Major
213
Rep 1,395
Posts |
Thanks - I guess
__________________
Club 6MT 2008 E92 M3 6MT, AW/Blk Ext., brushed aluminum 2006 E46 M3 ZCP 6MT Carbon blk/blk(sold) 2001 E46 325Xi 5MT Jet Blk/Blk (sold) |
Appreciate
0
|
03-24-2011, 03:28 PM | #12 |
Major
213
Rep 1,395
Posts |
haha - Canton, representing! I'm VERY familiar with the Mitten state. Please tell me you didn't buy your car from Erhard in Farmington...
__________________
Club 6MT 2008 E92 M3 6MT, AW/Blk Ext., brushed aluminum 2006 E46 M3 ZCP 6MT Carbon blk/blk(sold) 2001 E46 325Xi 5MT Jet Blk/Blk (sold) |
Appreciate
0
|
03-24-2011, 03:32 PM | #13 | |
Major General
258
Rep 5,012
Posts |
Quote:
EDRs are a fact of life in this litigious country now, just like cameras everywhere, and who knows what else, so just don't do anything stupid and you won't have anything to worry about . |
|
Appreciate
0
|
03-24-2011, 03:40 PM | #14 | |
Major
213
Rep 1,395
Posts |
Quote:
Just because someone obtains it with a laptop, doesn't mean it's not admissible. It can still be authenticated and have the foundation laid. The issue is whether or not it's even attainable in a useful form for Plaintiff's lawyers and law enforcement. This seems to remain the unanswered question here. I agree with the rest of your statement though
__________________
Club 6MT 2008 E92 M3 6MT, AW/Blk Ext., brushed aluminum 2006 E46 M3 ZCP 6MT Carbon blk/blk(sold) 2001 E46 325Xi 5MT Jet Blk/Blk (sold) |
|
Appreciate
0
|
03-24-2011, 03:46 PM | #15 | |
Captain
80
Rep 961
Posts |
Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
03-24-2011, 03:54 PM | #16 | |
Major
213
Rep 1,395
Posts |
Quote:
__________________
Club 6MT 2008 E92 M3 6MT, AW/Blk Ext., brushed aluminum 2006 E46 M3 ZCP 6MT Carbon blk/blk(sold) 2001 E46 325Xi 5MT Jet Blk/Blk (sold) |
|
Appreciate
0
|
03-24-2011, 04:06 PM | #17 | |
Captain
80
Rep 961
Posts |
Quote:
That said, the reasoning that I remember was that if you speed on the highway, it's in plain view and anyone who sees you do it can testify to that fact. Your EDR data, on the other hand, is not in plain view and nobody but you has access to it. The issue seems to hinge on the question of whether someone can, with no evidence whatever, download and investigate your EDR data to find out if you've been speeding. It's evidence if you're accused of a crime, but it's unlawful search and seizure if you're not. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
03-24-2011, 11:24 PM | #18 |
Lieutenant
96
Rep 545
Posts |
I had a chance to hear a little about EDR technology at a Toyota Technical class this last summer. We also reviewed the service procedures and reality of unintended acceleration in their vehicles.
There will be standardized EDR data coming I believe to the 2012 or 2013 vehicles much like the OBD-II standard for emission monitoring. As I was told there is a plan to make retrieval simpler and easier to display / graph. Currently most data is engineering based and requires specialized software to retrieve and someone trained in the interpretation of the data. Here are a few links about the systems: Introduction: http://www.blackboxofsecrets.com/ Types of information recorded (this varies by mfg.) http://airbagcrash.com/ State laws and privacy: http://www.ncsl.org/IssuesResearch/T...5/Default.aspx |
Appreciate
0
|
03-24-2011, 11:27 PM | #19 | |
Lieutenant
96
Rep 545
Posts |
Quote:
http://www.ncsl.org/IssuesResearch/T...5/Default.aspx Another great bit: http://www.injurysciences.com/Docume...ive%20EDRs.pdf Last edited by kenwelch; 03-24-2011 at 11:34 PM.. Reason: new additional link |
|
Appreciate
0
|
03-25-2011, 12:52 AM | #20 |
Major
175
Rep 1,379
Posts |
BMW is probably talking about the codes that the computer stores and used the word not to reffer to classical event data recorders like GM uses, but the use of the word is just a result of the translation from German.
__________________
Clean cars are happy cars! CANON PHOTOGRAPHER |
Appreciate
0
|
03-25-2011, 06:42 AM | #21 | |
Moderator
7512
Rep 19,368
Posts |
Quote:
Nope, I did not buy from Erhard. However, my previous E46 M3, which was my first BMW, was bought there. We'll take the rest of that discussion to PM. I bought my current E93 at Yark in Toledo, Ohio, and the 335i was actually purchased from a dealership in Missouri. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
Post Reply |
Bookmarks |
|
|