TT 2.0, 135i, A5, 335 coupe, 128i vert, C300

[NJKSC27]

ok well it turns out in September i will be shopping again because my FX is up on lease and i need a driveway mate for my G. And those are my choices right now. as many of you know I passed on the 135 because the lease was out of the roof. but things seems to be calming down now. so as of now these are what the girlfriend and i have narrowed it down to. and here is how we feel. these are our concerns. performance is not number one to us either. opinions please

135i
overall best bang for the buck, not sold on looks, kinda small, not many amenities.

A5, S-Line
slightly over priced, looks are badass, interior is the best, exclusive

TT 2.0
styling is great, audi quality, SMALL ( a negative), again, slightly pricey

335 coupe
styling is so so unless we get sport, might be dated soon, performance is of course above all

128i vert
because the GF wants it

C300 4 matic, sport
not sure about a sedan (but we already have the G), quality is top notch, styling is A+, features and amenities are pretty good, hardly any performance aspects though

:iono:

[mtla4]

LOL youre on 1addicts people will say the 1. Since youre in NJ id go with the c300 c350 because the g37 is already a pain in the winter.

[NJKSC27]

Originally Posted by mtla4

LOL youre on 1addicts people will say the 1. Since youre in NJ id go with the c300 c350 because the g37 is already a pain in the winter.

haha i know, thats why i posted in "General/Other Cars Talk". But over the year everyone here seems pretty fair with their opinions here.

the Benz is kinda "stuffy" though. if you know what i mean

[mtla4]

Originally Posted by NJKSC27

haha i know, thats why i posted in "General/Other Cars Talk". But over the year everyone here seems pretty fair with their opinions here.

the Benz is kinda "stuffy" though. if you know what i mean

Or wait for the new A4..Honestly from an FX to a 2 door rwd car...you will probably need some room as the G37 trunk is pretty small.Id skip the 1 series in your case and jump either to a 3er or something else. We all need *That* car and the 1 doesnt fit the bill.

[RickR]

It's a tough decision. I had a c230 sport for about four years and while I liked the car, I never really bonded with the stick in the benz. I looked at cars for about a year, finally narrowing down my choice to the Audi TT and the Boxster.

I was about to pull the trigger on the TT when I drove a 128 convertible on a lark. The 128 just blew me away. Although I prefer the TT's styling, the 128 excelled in most other areas - I found it quieter, more solid, more connected to the road.

[Brandon26pdx]

C300 with the auto trans and 4-matic will probably be kind of slow. Dunno, depends on what you really need...AWD? 4 doors or 2?

[NJKSC27]

see thats the thing, i dont NEED anything. and ill go from looking at a roadster to a 4 matic sedan.

[ichiban]

A5.

[AchtungF80]

My FX lease is up in December, so technically, I too am going from an FX to a 135i and don't mind it at all...gonna experiment w/snow tires on the E30 for the 2-3 significant snowfalls we have every year. Worse comes to worse - I will buy a 1996-99 Jeep Grand Cherokee for the snow for $2500-3000 but we will see.

[john970]

Originally Posted by NJKSC27

the Benz is kinda "stuffy" though. if you know what i mean

Yeah, and I agree. the best part about the 1er is it isn't sold on looks like you say, so i wouldn't be embarrassed to drive a 1er to volunteer at a school or shelter where a cayman or a benz would probably have me getting a ride.

benz's are big and dont seem to be about the driving experience as much, or at least not about the sporty driving experience.

[Crowley]

I say the A5 if you can afford it ..

Crowley

[NJKSC27]

Originally Posted by Crowley

I say the A5 if you can afford it ..

Crowley

yea thats what i am leaning toward

[BMW Dreamer]

135i
335i
A5 S-line

I don't like the others.

I wish the new 265hp T 2.0 S3 Sportback would come here. CRAP

[john970]

I'd go for the S5 in your position. Only reason I didn't consider it was it's NA, and wouldn't therefore compete with the 135 up here in Denver.

That car has a SICK interior - feels like a bentley.

[BMW Dreamer]

Originally Posted by NJKSC27

yea thats what i am leaning toward

If you get an A5 with the S-line pkg you also have to get the premium pkg. That takes the price north of $45k, without it loaded. 0-60 6.1 vs 4.8 in the 135i.

[NJKSC27]

Originally Posted by Jeff1962

If you get an A5 with the S-line pkg you also have to get the premium pkg. That takes the price north of $45k, without it loaded. 0-60 6.1 vs 4.8 in the 135i.

yea i know but performance is not a priority, i already have G37S. And i think the styling of the audi beats the 135.

[BMW Dreamer]

Originally Posted by NJKSC27

yea i know but performance is not a priority, i already have G37S. And i think the styling of the audi beats the 135.

I looked at a white S5 last sunday and it was real nice. TOO much $$$ for myself.

[NJKSC27]

Originally Posted by Jeff1962

I looked at a white S5 last sunday and it was real nice. TOO much $$$ for myself.

yea S5 vs A5 with S-Line are two different animals. S5 is pretty sweet

[Brandon26pdx]

Originally Posted by NJKSC27

see thats the thing, i dont NEED anything. and ill go from looking at a roadster to a 4 matic sedan.

Therein might lie the problem.:iono:

[Brandon26pdx]

S5 is a little out of the box pricewise compared to everything else listed. Those are like $60k with a few choice options. Realistically it's up there in the M3/C63/IS-F/RS-4 price range.

[blue-coupe]

I LOVE the A5 S-Line. The S5 is just overkill in my opinion.

[MIGCAL]

Originally Posted by blue-coupe

I LOVE the A5 S-Line. The S5 is just overkill in my opinion.

There is no such thing as over kill :-)