T.C.E. Review: Not bad

M3onTwomps · 07-18-2007, 05:11 PM

Carenthusiast.com -- Is that a V8 under your bonnet or are you just happy to see me? - Shane O' Donoghue

| First Drive | Ascari Race Circuit, Spain | BMW M3 Coupé |

Opinions are like arses; everyone has one. But sometimes it sounds like the former is coming out of the latter. This is especially true in the case of reviewing a car (a fairly inexact science at the best of times), in particular when a new model has been hyped up so much that expectations are incredibly high. The latest BMW M3 falls into this category.

How could it not? The M3 lineage began in 1986 with the E30-based model, developed and sold as a road car only to homologate BMW’s new Touring Car racer. Twenty years later, BMW has sold an incredible 180,000 M3s worldwide, 56,000 of those accounted for by the outgoing E46 Coupé. Projected sales figures of the new car are even higher. We're not talking about an average family car here; this is a high-performance rear-wheel drive sportscar that can hold its own against a Porsche 911.

The details of the new M3 were released early on; with the fitment of a V8 engine no shock. BMW's official figures for the new 4.0-litre powerplant surprisingly don't pip those for the Audi RS4, the M3's biggest rival (until the C 63 AMG Merc arrives). Peak power for the M3 is quoted as 414bhp at a heady 8,300rpm, while maximum torque is a little down on the Audi's at 295lb.ft, produced at 3,900rpm. Before driving the M3, you'd be forgiven for expecting an engine that needs to be revved to keep on the boil, but dig a little deeper into the unit's specification before making that judgement.

A glance at the torque curve indicates that 85% of the maximum torque figure is available from 2,000rpm to the red line at 8,400rpm. This is made possible by the use of double-VANOS. Variable Nockenwellen Steuerung is the German name, or in English, continuously variable valve timing on both inlet and exhaust camshafts. Another significant development is the elimination of standard vibration-measuring knock sensors. Instead, BMW uses the spark plugs to detect and analyse the ion current in each cylinder, allowing the engine's computer to maximise the spark advance for any given condition. A higher compression ratio is then possible, which in turn leads to greater thermal efficiency, more power and less fuel consumption. On top of that, BMW fits individual throttle butterflies to the inlet ports, said to enhance engine response.

Enough technical mumbo jumbo I hear you say; what does it feel like? In a word: awesome. There is not a single hole in the engine's delivery and you never feel short of go. Use every last horse and all the rev counter and you are rewarded with ferocious pace accompanied by a spine-tingling, hard-edged V8 exhaust note. Just like the old car, the rev counter seems to go on forever. Not in the mood to wake the dead? That's ok, the M3 is no slouch when you slot a higher gear either, moving from a quiet, high-speed cruise, to illegally fast in one swift shove on the big pedal. It's a very flexible unit, so much so that we found second gear to be pretty useless most of the time, on road and track.

Our two days at the wheel included a few hundred miles on challenging mountain roads, topped off by about twenty laps of the Ascari race circuit. On the road, the M3 proved to be formidable, with huge grip afforded by the new Michelin Pilot Sport tyres and a wonderfully throttle adjustable stance. An early review of the car suggested that it suffered from excess understeer, but we reckon this was due to a sector of the test route that was coated in a thin layer of dust with precious little grip. Even at low speeds, the M3 slithered around on this road, although it was a lot of fun and perfectly controllable.

BMW did admit that it asked Michelin for a front tyre compound that promoted initial stabilising understeer, which is present, but get the car turned in with the weight over the nose and use the throttle sensibly and there is nothing but delicious neutrality to the car's stance. There is plenty of torque available to edge the rear end out if desired and laps at the circuit showed how controllable the new M3 is in a gentle four-wheel drift, even at high speeds. Serious drifting fans will be glad to hear that the new car features a new Variable M Differential, which has the ability to feed as much as 100% of the engine's output to the rear tyre with the most grip, though this plays a major part in regular 'enthusiastic' cornering too.

As with the M5 and M6, the owner of the new M3 has a wealth of customisation options to hand. A so-called 'MDrive Manager' groups the settings into one mode the driver can choose with a single button on the steering wheel. Throttle and power steering calibrations may be chosen, as can the level of traction control. An optional extra will be the Electronic Damper Control (EDC), with three selectable levels. The test cars in Spain all had this feature and we think it's invaluable, allowing the M3 to be just as comfortable as any other 3 Series Coupé until you want that little bit more body control. Even on its hardest setting, the car is not uncomfortable and the system certainly helps the M3 feel light on its feet.

Where the extra weight will tell is on tyre and brake wear, especially with prolonged track usage - though we're not so sure how many M3 owners in UK or Ireland venture onto a circuit with their pride and joy. We had no problem on the road in Spain (other than a characteristic rumble from the discs when hot), though our own road routes back home will be a better test of the brakes. Next month, we'll get the chance to give the car its full shakedown in right-hand drive format, including a trip to the Nurburgring, a circuit the M3 was developed extensively on.

Some of the first reviews of the new M3 have suggested that the writers' expectations were not met. It was recommended by some that punters wait for the 135i Coupé rather than opt for the new M-car. This advice seems to centre on the fact that the new M3 is heavier, larger and more expensive than the much-loved outgoing model.

Yet the facts are these: the new M3 is based on the safer, more refined, more comfortable, and more capable E92 3 Series Coupé. Yes, it does weigh nearly 100kg more than the previous car, but it substantially out-performs it, uses less fuel and emits less pollutants. Yes, it does cost about £5,000 more (€12,000 more in Ireland), but I suspect that if you offered owners of the current car an upgrade package that brought their car to the elevated level of the new M3 in all areas, they'd bite your hand off at twice the price. Well that's my opinion anyway. You can make up your own mind from September, when the new BMW M3 goes on sale.

Performance: *****
Explosive, and yet the way the performance is delivered deserves praise even more than the outright pace itself.

Engine & Transmission: ****
Fears that the loss of the soulful straight-six would mean a car with less character are unfounded. The new unit is nothing short of a masterpiece. The manual 'box is not quite as slick as we'd like though.

Ride & Handling: *****
A degree more feedback through the steering wheel would be welcome, but with the selectable electronic damper control, the M3 manages to be comfortable as well as an inspiring car to drive. It tackles track work with aplomb too.

Fuel Economy: ****
After two days of rather hard driving (including nearly twenty laps of the Ascari track), a not so impressive average of 13.5mpg was indicated... BMW quotes 23mpg on the Combined Cycle, which is surprisingly a little better than the outgoing car.

Tactility: ****
First impressions suggest that steering feel is a little wanting and that the gear lever springing is not to our tastes. However, the new M3 is of much higher quality than the outgoing car, and all contact surfaces are good to touch.

Appearance: *****
What's not to like? Even on the standard 18-inch wheels, the new M3 looks stunning, thanks in no small part to its carbon-fibre roof and the suggestive bonnet bulge.

Interior: *****
The classy 3 Series Coupé interior benefits from subtle 'M' upgrades and what should be a decent level of standard equipment. It also manages to transport four adults and quite a bit of luggage.

Safety: *****
The regular 3 Series received five stars for adult occupant protection in the Euro NCAP safety tests.

Equipment & Value for Money: ****
The hike in price from the outgoing car will potentially alienate owners of a current car looking to trade in, but when you look at the gap in ability between the cars, the hike seems quite reasonable!

Technical Specifications

Performance, emissions & economy

Top speed (mph): 155
0-62 mph (seconds): 4.8

Urban mpg: 15.8
Extra urban mpg: 30.7
Combined mpg: 22.8
CO2 (g/km): 295

Chassis & running gear

Front: Aluminium two-joint spring strut axle with tiebar; small, positive compensation of transverse forces; reduction of brake dive.

Rear: Five-arm axle with anti-squat and anti-dive.

Steering: Rack and pinion, Servotronic power steering.

Turning circle diameter (m): 11.70

Brakes: Single-piston swing-calliper compound vented and cross-drilled disc brakes all round. Front: 360 x 30mm. Rear: 350 x 24mm. ABS, ASC, CBC, DSC.

Wheels: Forged aluminium alloys. Front: 8.5J x 18-inch. Rear: 9.5J x 18-inch.

Tyres: Michelin Pilot Sport developed in conjunction with the car. Front: 245/40 ZR18. Rear: 265/40 ZR18.

Engine & transmission

Engine: V8 petrol engine mounted longitudinally in front.

Management: Emissions controlled to Euro IV.

Cubic capacity (cc): 3999
Compression ratio: 12.00:1
Bore x stroke (mm): 92.00 x 75.20
Valve gear: Four valves per cylinder, double overhead camshafts. Double-VANOS variable valve timing on both camshafts.
Max. power (bhp): 414 at 8300 rpm
Max. torque (lb.ft): 295 at 3900 rpm

Transmission: Six-speed manual. Rear-wheel drive. Variable M Differential.

Gear ratios:
1st: 4.055:1
2nd: 2.369:1
3rd: 1.582:1
4th: 1.192:1
5th: 1.000:1
6th: 0.872:1
Reverse: 3.678:1
Final drive: 3.846:1

Dimensions & weights

Length (mm): 4615
Height (mm): 1424
Width (mm): 1804
Wheelbase (mm): 2761
Front track (mm): 1538
Rear track (mm): 1539
Cargo volume (litres): 430
Gross weight (kg): 2080
Kerb weight (kg): 1655
Fuel tank capacity (litres): 63

http://www.carenthusiast.com/roadtes...rticle&id=1967

M3onTwomps · 07-18-2007, 06:20 PM

It's funny.

I've posted three reviews that seem to praise the new M3 and there's absolutely zero comments on all three.

Kinda proves that the "RS4 beats the M3" cover will sell more mags.

13eastie · 07-18-2007, 06:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by M3onTwomps

It's funny.

I've posted three reviews that seem to praise the new M3 and there's absolutely zero comments on all three.

Kinda proves that the "RS4 beats the M3" cover will sell more mags.

There are a lot of people reading what they want to read around here nowadays. There haven't been many truly objective comments made and it's fairly difficult to argue against BS.

M3onTwomps · 07-18-2007, 06:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 13eastie

There are a lot of people reading what they want to read around here nowadays. There haven't been many truly objective comments made and it's fairly difficult to argue against BS.

Yeah...I kinda figured as much. Looking forward to some more concrete competitions.

chonko · 07-18-2007, 06:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by M3onTwomps

It's funny.

I've posted three reviews that seem to praise the new M3 and there's absolutely zero comments on all three.

Kinda proves that the "RS4 beats the M3" cover will sell more mags.

People for some reason would rather discuss negative reviews/issues than positive ones.
I know exactly what you mean.

RandyB · 07-18-2007, 06:52 PM

That one sounds very positive on just about all fronts. I love what I'm hearing about the engine especially!

swamp2 · 07-18-2007, 06:57 PM

Indeed, nice write up. Definitely noteworthy that this fellow waited to read other initial reviews to write his and that he specifically criticized the expectations and conclusions of others.

On an fairly unrelated note we have a verification here of BMW asking Michelin for tires with a bit (or a bit more) understeer. I had initially bagged on a fairly poor early review of the car that made this claim and cited this as a potential red flag to the accuracy of that review. I guess we can count this as verification that this was indeed the request and delivery from Michelin. Perhpas the chassis and suspension is really almost perfectly neutral and then the tires give the small understeer (which is the only way a mass produced car should be delivered to the general public).

lucid · 07-18-2007, 07:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by M3onTwomps

It's funny.

I've posted three reviews that seem to praise the new M3 and there's absolutely zero comments on all three.

Kinda proves that the "RS4 beats the M3" cover will sell more mags.

I think the "RS4 beats M3" type of review attracts the trolls since they feel like they are well supported in their opinion; the review says so doesn't it! In other words, they can troll around more effectively on those threads, and somebody eventually makes the mistake of responding, things heat up, and once a critical mass is reached, everybody jumps in; hence the high number of views...

888 · 07-19-2007, 06:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by M3onTwomps

It's funny.

I've posted three reviews that seem to praise the new M3 and there's absolutely zero comments on all three.

Kinda proves that the "RS4 beats the M3" cover will sell more mags.

Dog bites man never makes the news, but when man bites dog it will make headlines!

Thanks for the post!

888 · 07-19-2007, 06:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swamp2

small understeer (which is the only way a mass produced car should be delivered to the general public).

+1

BruceWain · 07-19-2007, 07:14 AM

+2

07-18-2007, 05:11 PM	#1
M3onTwomps First Lieutenant 7 Rep 319 Posts Drives: '02 E46 M3 Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: The Sandbox iTrader: (0)	T.C.E. Review: Not bad Carenthusiast.com -- Is that a V8 under your bonnet or are you just happy to see me? - Shane O' Donoghue \| First Drive \| Ascari Race Circuit, Spain \| BMW M3 Coupé \| Opinions are like arses; everyone has one. But sometimes it sounds like the former is coming out of the latter. This is especially true in the case of reviewing a car (a fairly inexact science at the best of times), in particular when a new model has been hyped up so much that expectations are incredibly high. The latest BMW M3 falls into this category. How could it not? The M3 lineage began in 1986 with the E30-based model, developed and sold as a road car only to homologate BMW’s new Touring Car racer. Twenty years later, BMW has sold an incredible 180,000 M3s worldwide, 56,000 of those accounted for by the outgoing E46 Coupé. Projected sales figures of the new car are even higher. We're not talking about an average family car here; this is a high-performance rear-wheel drive sportscar that can hold its own against a Porsche 911. The details of the new M3 were released early on; with the fitment of a V8 engine no shock. BMW's official figures for the new 4.0-litre powerplant surprisingly don't pip those for the Audi RS4, the M3's biggest rival (until the C 63 AMG Merc arrives). Peak power for the M3 is quoted as 414bhp at a heady 8,300rpm, while maximum torque is a little down on the Audi's at 295lb.ft, produced at 3,900rpm. Before driving the M3, you'd be forgiven for expecting an engine that needs to be revved to keep on the boil, but dig a little deeper into the unit's specification before making that judgement. A glance at the torque curve indicates that 85% of the maximum torque figure is available from 2,000rpm to the red line at 8,400rpm. This is made possible by the use of double-VANOS. Variable Nockenwellen Steuerung is the German name, or in English, continuously variable valve timing on both inlet and exhaust camshafts. Another significant development is the elimination of standard vibration-measuring knock sensors. Instead, BMW uses the spark plugs to detect and analyse the ion current in each cylinder, allowing the engine's computer to maximise the spark advance for any given condition. A higher compression ratio is then possible, which in turn leads to greater thermal efficiency, more power and less fuel consumption. On top of that, BMW fits individual throttle butterflies to the inlet ports, said to enhance engine response. Enough technical mumbo jumbo I hear you say; what does it feel like? In a word: awesome. There is not a single hole in the engine's delivery and you never feel short of go. Use every last horse and all the rev counter and you are rewarded with ferocious pace accompanied by a spine-tingling, hard-edged V8 exhaust note. Just like the old car, the rev counter seems to go on forever. Not in the mood to wake the dead? That's ok, the M3 is no slouch when you slot a higher gear either, moving from a quiet, high-speed cruise, to illegally fast in one swift shove on the big pedal. It's a very flexible unit, so much so that we found second gear to be pretty useless most of the time, on road and track. Our two days at the wheel included a few hundred miles on challenging mountain roads, topped off by about twenty laps of the Ascari race circuit. On the road, the M3 proved to be formidable, with huge grip afforded by the new Michelin Pilot Sport tyres and a wonderfully throttle adjustable stance. An early review of the car suggested that it suffered from excess understeer, but we reckon this was due to a sector of the test route that was coated in a thin layer of dust with precious little grip. Even at low speeds, the M3 slithered around on this road, although it was a lot of fun and perfectly controllable. BMW did admit that it asked Michelin for a front tyre compound that promoted initial stabilising understeer, which is present, but get the car turned in with the weight over the nose and use the throttle sensibly and there is nothing but delicious neutrality to the car's stance. There is plenty of torque available to edge the rear end out if desired and laps at the circuit showed how controllable the new M3 is in a gentle four-wheel drift, even at high speeds. Serious drifting fans will be glad to hear that the new car features a new Variable M Differential, which has the ability to feed as much as 100% of the engine's output to the rear tyre with the most grip, though this plays a major part in regular 'enthusiastic' cornering too. As with the M5 and M6, the owner of the new M3 has a wealth of customisation options to hand. A so-called 'MDrive Manager' groups the settings into one mode the driver can choose with a single button on the steering wheel. Throttle and power steering calibrations may be chosen, as can the level of traction control. An optional extra will be the Electronic Damper Control (EDC), with three selectable levels. The test cars in Spain all had this feature and we think it's invaluable, allowing the M3 to be just as comfortable as any other 3 Series Coupé until you want that little bit more body control. Even on its hardest setting, the car is not uncomfortable and the system certainly helps the M3 feel light on its feet. Where the extra weight will tell is on tyre and brake wear, especially with prolonged track usage - though we're not so sure how many M3 owners in UK or Ireland venture onto a circuit with their pride and joy. We had no problem on the road in Spain (other than a characteristic rumble from the discs when hot), though our own road routes back home will be a better test of the brakes. Next month, we'll get the chance to give the car its full shakedown in right-hand drive format, including a trip to the Nurburgring, a circuit the M3 was developed extensively on. Some of the first reviews of the new M3 have suggested that the writers' expectations were not met. It was recommended by some that punters wait for the 135i Coupé rather than opt for the new M-car. This advice seems to centre on the fact that the new M3 is heavier, larger and more expensive than the much-loved outgoing model. Yet the facts are these: the new M3 is based on the safer, more refined, more comfortable, and more capable E92 3 Series Coupé. Yes, it does weigh nearly 100kg more than the previous car, but it substantially out-performs it, uses less fuel and emits less pollutants. Yes, it does cost about £5,000 more (€12,000 more in Ireland), but I suspect that if you offered owners of the current car an upgrade package that brought their car to the elevated level of the new M3 in all areas, they'd bite your hand off at twice the price. Well that's my opinion anyway. You can make up your own mind from September, when the new BMW M3 goes on sale. Performance: *** Explosive, and yet the way the performance is delivered deserves praise even more than the outright pace itself. Engine & Transmission: Fears that the loss of the soulful straight-six would mean a car with less character are unfounded. The new unit is nothing short of a masterpiece. The manual 'box is not quite as slick as we'd like though. Ride & Handling: * A degree more feedback through the steering wheel would be welcome, but with the selectable electronic damper control, the M3 manages to be comfortable as well as an inspiring car to drive. It tackles track work with aplomb too. Fuel Economy: After two days of rather hard driving (including nearly twenty laps of the Ascari track), a not so impressive average of 13.5mpg was indicated... BMW quotes 23mpg on the Combined Cycle, which is surprisingly a little better than the outgoing car. Tactility: First impressions suggest that steering feel is a little wanting and that the gear lever springing is not to our tastes. However, the new M3 is of much higher quality than the outgoing car, and all contact surfaces are good to touch. Appearance: * What's not to like? Even on the standard 18-inch wheels, the new M3 looks stunning, thanks in no small part to its carbon-fibre roof and the suggestive bonnet bulge. Interior: * The classy 3 Series Coupé interior benefits from subtle 'M' upgrades and what should be a decent level of standard equipment. It also manages to transport four adults and quite a bit of luggage. Safety: * The regular 3 Series received five stars for adult occupant protection in the Euro NCAP safety tests. Equipment & Value for Money: ** The hike in price from the outgoing car will potentially alienate owners of a current car looking to trade in, but when you look at the gap in ability between the cars, the hike seems quite reasonable! Technical Specifications Performance, emissions & economy Top speed (mph): 155 0-62 mph (seconds): 4.8 Urban mpg: 15.8 Extra urban mpg: 30.7 Combined mpg: 22.8 CO2 (g/km): 295 Chassis & running gear Front: Aluminium two-joint spring strut axle with tiebar; small, positive compensation of transverse forces; reduction of brake dive. Rear: Five-arm axle with anti-squat and anti-dive. Steering: Rack and pinion, Servotronic power steering. Turning circle diameter (m): 11.70 Brakes: Single-piston swing-calliper compound vented and cross-drilled disc brakes all round. Front: 360 x 30mm. Rear: 350 x 24mm. ABS, ASC, CBC, DSC. Wheels: Forged aluminium alloys. Front: 8.5J x 18-inch. Rear: 9.5J x 18-inch. Tyres: Michelin Pilot Sport developed in conjunction with the car. Front: 245/40 ZR18. Rear: 265/40 ZR18. Engine & transmission Engine: V8 petrol engine mounted longitudinally in front. Management: Emissions controlled to Euro IV. Cubic capacity (cc): 3999 Compression ratio: 12.00:1 Bore x stroke (mm): 92.00 x 75.20 Valve gear: Four valves per cylinder, double overhead camshafts. Double-VANOS variable valve timing on both camshafts. Max. power (bhp): 414 at 8300 rpm Max. torque (lb.ft): 295 at 3900 rpm Transmission: Six-speed manual. Rear-wheel drive. Variable M Differential. Gear ratios: 1st: 4.055:1 2nd: 2.369:1 3rd: 1.582:1 4th: 1.192:1 5th: 1.000:1 6th: 0.872:1 Reverse: 3.678:1 Final drive: 3.846:1 Dimensions & weights Length (mm): 4615 Height (mm): 1424 Width (mm): 1804 Wheelbase (mm): 2761 Front track (mm): 1538 Rear track (mm): 1539 Cargo volume (litres): 430 Gross weight (kg): 2080 Kerb weight (kg): 1655 Fuel tank capacity (litres): 63 http://www.carenthusiast.com/roadtes...rticle&id=1967
	Appreciate 0 Tweet Quote

07-18-2007, 06:20 PM	#2
M3onTwomps First Lieutenant 7 Rep 319 Posts Drives: '02 E46 M3 Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: The Sandbox iTrader: (0)	It's funny. I've posted three reviews that seem to praise the new M3 and there's absolutely zero comments on all three. Kinda proves that the "RS4 beats the M3" cover will sell more mags.
	Appreciate 0 Quote

07-18-2007, 06:52 PM	#6
RandyB Lieutenant Colonel 20 Rep 1,504 Posts Drives: '03 330i, '09 M3 Coupe Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: Texas iTrader: (0)	That one sounds very positive on just about all fronts. I love what I'm hearing about the engine especially!
	Appreciate 0 Quote

07-18-2007, 06:57 PM	#7
swamp2 Lieutenant General 609 Rep 10,407 Posts Drives: E92 M3 Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: San Diego, CA USA iTrader: (3)	Various Indeed, nice write up. Definitely noteworthy that this fellow waited to read other initial reviews to write his and that he specifically criticized the expectations and conclusions of others. On an fairly unrelated note we have a verification here of BMW asking Michelin for tires with a bit (or a bit more) understeer. I had initially bagged on a fairly poor early review of the car that made this claim and cited this as a potential red flag to the accuracy of that review. I guess we can count this as verification that this was indeed the request and delivery from Michelin. Perhpas the chassis and suspension is really almost perfectly neutral and then the tires give the small understeer (which is the only way a mass produced car should be delivered to the general public).
	Appreciate 0 Quote

07-19-2007, 07:14 AM	#11
BruceWain Private 0 Rep 66 Posts Drives: You Crazy Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: NJ iTrader: (0)	+2
	Appreciate 0 Quote