Good info, thanks Singletrack. It only ground when I let the clutch back out and it wasn't fully seated into 2nd. Otherwise it felt like a collar when I pushed it into 2nd all the way. Like it had some resistance but not too much. The other gears have ZERO resistance though so I thought this was odd, esp. when I had just read this topic this morning while cruising these forums..
If I end up buying it, I'm going to make sure the fluid gets changed out and comment to the dealer about it. Actually the one I'm buying (MAYBE) is a different one, so I will test drive that one too, it was just getting CPO'd and I couldn't drive it today.