Guys this is not a pissing contest. We are all entitled to our opinions so let's leave it at that.
Serge, you are describing exactly how I felt when I drove the vette 2 years ago. It feels big, but incredibly capable. I love that the car sits low to the ground and stays flat through the turns. But now that I think about it, my complaints with my E46M was that I thought it was a little big
I've now decided to throw in the Z4M into the ring, which I view as a hybrid of the E46M and C6. I can maintain some creature comforts but with a very sports car feel.