View Single Post
      12-31-2006, 11:33 AM   #14
devo
Colonel
United_States
755
Rep
2,736
Posts

Drives: Bimmers & Porsches
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Atlanta

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Crea View Post
i guess none of u know gear ratio makes a huge difference in acceleration time

7spd SMG has a much closer gear ration compare to the 6MT, hence faster acceleration and the 7spd allows the V10 to be kept inside its powerband better then the 6MT

this is what i found on the M5 Forums:


Some thoughts about the comparative gearing of the E60 M5 SMG vs. 6-Speed manual:

-Both cars share the same 3.62 Final Drive.

-5th, 6th, and 7th gears in the 7-Speed SMG share virtually the same ratios as 4th, 5th, and 6th in the 6-Speed manual! (i.e. 4th gear in the 6-Speed manual is 2.5% shorter than 5th in the SMG, 5th in the 6-Speed manual is DEAD IDENTICAL to 6th in the SMG, and 6th in the 6-Speed manual is 4.5% shorter than 7th in the SMG).

-The "extra" gear in the 7-Speed SMG is found in the 2nd-3rd-4th area of the SMG gearbox (i.e. as compared to the six gears in the manual gearbox).

-1st gear in the SMG is 1.8% taller / longer than 1st gear in the 6-Speed manual.

-Reverse gear is 7.8% shorter on the SMG (i.e. 3.99 for SMG vs. 3.68 for 6-Speed


GUSTAV'S REPLY TO ME: But for "everyday racing" it seems like the manual


will see the taillights of the SMG, since most normal races do occur in the 2,3,4 gear area. Quote:
Originally Posted by Gustav
Thanks to HadE55NowM5 I posted the gearign charts:




BMW E60/E63 SMG


1st 3.99 45 mph (73 km/h) @8250 rpm


2nd 2.65 68 mph (110 km/h) @8250 rpm


3rd 1.81 101 mph (164 km/h) @8250 rpm


4th 1.39 131 mph (213 km/h) @8250 rpm


5th 1.16 158 mph (256 km/h) @8250 rpm


6th 1.00 171 mph (277 km/h) @?


7th 0.83 ? ??



Final Drive: 3.62





BMW E60 6-Speed Manual


1st 4.06


2nd 2.40


3rd 1.58


4th 1.19


5th 1.00


6th 0.87


Final Drive: 3.62
Some of us know that gear ratios make a difference in acceleration!

You did post some informative data. It clearly points out one if the advantages of SMG. The close ratio gearing of the SEVEN speed SMG may pursuade me to go that route, IF, I'm confident that BMW has made the E90's shifting less jerking and/or sloppy. It's the close ratios and the choice of seven gears that does it for me, not the fact that SMG shifts faster in S7 mode.
Appreciate 0