[Dan Halen]

Having owned an 6MT S5 a couple years back, as well as tracked both it and my 6MT M3, from a driver's enjoyment standpoint, the M3 delivers a lot more. It's a much more athletic feeling car, more visceral, more tossable, engine note, etc, etc, etc. I am very happy to have the M, but still at little verklempt at times thinking of my old Pcar.

Sadly, I think the S5 with the JHM short shifter was a little smoother than the M3 with the current SS I have installed... and thats kind of inexcusable from the M division IMO.


And I am not a BMW fan boy- I pick based on what moves me- but M3 if you're a driver.

Also- Why did i waste me time typing this?! F***in internet