I finally had my day in small claims court with them and just got the decision back by mail. The Commisioner (not Judge unfortunately) seemed good on prior cases of the day but got lost really quickly with mine. She had absolutely no idea about cars, maintenance, service, aftermarket parts, etc. Zero, zip, zlich. I had to explain the simplest of things over and over again (per her requests actually). She also seemed to be confused on the fact that cosmetic damage on a nice wheel is very real and serious to the owner.
Anyway I did win my case, however her "cop out" was awarding me a small fraction of the total amount I was seeking and entitled to (about 25% or so). I can't stand these half-baked/cop out type of decisions. Her ruling clearly shows fault and since they were at fault they should pay for all of the damage they caused. Plain and simple.
Anyway, in short, steer very clear of this place.