I'd take the Fit. It's the biggest bargain on the market today - not many $16k cars are as flexible, spacious, and well equipped as the Fit. I love German cars, but it's still tough to beat the overall reliability of a Honda. And it's actually pretty fun to drive too.
'15 i3 REX // Capparis // ZGW // ZTD // HK // 20"
20% Tint, Coding, LED High Beams/Signals, Painted Reflectors, MAX2 Hardwire
Past: F30 335i, E90 328xi