LMAO . . . there are some real pieces of work in this thread. I know it's a rather sordid pleasure, but it's really fun to watch people knocking themselves out trying to "win" "un-winnable" arguments.
Everything in the engineering world is an exercise in pros and cons (AKA trade-offs). There is never one "right answer," but some people will never get that concept.
My own bias is shared with that of the late Sir Colin Chapman. Lose a lot of weight first, and then figure out what your power needs are.
By all means, keep going boys--you'll never win the FI vs. NA peeing contest, but it sure is fun to watch.