Hats off to Brad and his crew at Braiden Tire, they figured out the problem. Seems my air intake for my ESS kit on the drivers side was pushing on the wheel liner and reducing the clearance for the wheels. Adjustments were made and fits great now. I ended up going with the R888 for now as the price point was a no brainer, less than half the Nittos. If I burn through them I'll get Nittos next.
2010 M3 E93 AW / 6MT / ESS VT2 600 / Dinan Free Flow Exhaust / Dinan High Flow Middle Racing Exhaust / Dinan Racing Coil-Over Suspension / HRE P40SC / Michelin PSS 255/35/19 295/30/19