In general, I dig pin stripes. There is local guy, "Sid" who is pretty famous around here. He usually writes "SID DID IT" in small letters above the gas door. I had my '91 M5 pin striped. It was black and I did the M colors.
It's tough to tell in your pics, but it does seem oddly placed. Perhaps take some better photos (up close and full view) and maybe you'll change some of the mind of some of the haters
M in love