Originally Posted by ragingclue
I have heard horror stories about virtually all insurance companies though, to include GEICO. Some companies seem to be worse than others in that regard (Progressive), but I can say that I've had nothing but good experiences with GEICO, to include a totaled modded E36 M3 which they let me pull as many mods off as I could get to.
I had lots of military buddies with good experience with USAA too.
I actually had good experience with Progressive but I've only used them for motorcycles, not cars. I think, as with anything, it depends on who you get when making a claim.