Originally Posted by ChrisK
I'm not paying for it, discount tire is. It has to be repaired now.
The repair will be worse than that damage. It will look good for about 2 weeks then all the brake dust will stick to where ever they refinish the wheel. Trust me, if they aren't willing to have the whole wheel refinished I would just leave it. I've had my front ZCP wheel repaired at BMW, and it looks like hell now several months later.