Seeing as you haven't checked around for tires in a couple of years I'm assuming you haven't replaced them for the same amount of time. If that's the case then why are you looking for an affordable set? Just pick up some PSS and enjoy them for the years to come.
Current: 2013 Fire Orange E92 M w/orange stitching
Previous: 2011 Jet Black E92 M - 2006 325xi E90 NON-M - 2009 Volkswagen 2.0FSI MK5