Just to update, car is at the shop. Should get it back by thursday. In the meantime, I guess I got a little gun shy about the Performance spoiler so I ordered some white vinyl to see if I could subdue the carbon fiber some. The color match is, of course, not perfect but I think it will give me a good idea if I want to have it painted or just go with the whole CF look. In any case, I think the wrap turned out pretty well.
You can see the color mismatch when compared to the original AW spoiler. Thats a scrap piece of the vinyl on there.