I can't vote because they all have their strengths.
The mustang = power but no handling unless modded, and I'm assuming bad gas mileage for a daily
The S2000 = handling but no power unless modded, would be good on gas
The Evo X (I had one) = equals handling better than both and power without modding, but average gas mileage gotta stay out of boost
which will be hard to do. You could always modify these and get great power out of them as well. I sold mine because the motor sounds like doo-doo to me stock or exhaust. I couldn't find one I like to suit it, plus I came from the Subie world and there's nothing like the boxer rumble.
After all that I can vote, the EVO seems like the better choice of the 3, AWD for winter too...
Thank you for the penny!