Tried both. The weights migrate under the aluminum tape until they work their way out. A couple strips of gorilla tape is what works for me. Got lucky recently b/c one front wheel didn't need any weights! 1/2 Problem solved!
Bring both to the track and try them out. GL
E92 M3 2011 Jet Black/Black/Carbon
Mods: painted reflectors | broken valve spring E90 (sold)