Any reason my old tire shine didn't do this? Should I just be more careful when applying this tire shine to not get it on the wheel at all? If so, not sure if its' worth it. The hot shine, I could simply spray on, not worry about overspray on the wheel, let it dry and go. No problems like this afterwards...
I'll definitely try your suggestion for cleaning. I tried a wheel cleaner and it didn't seem to do much so I'll try the all purpose cleaner or something. Maybe simple green?