Well if you're going to do shift by wire
Why can't you install a manual gearshift knob, that controls the automatic transmission?
So I tell the transmission when to shift
It would feel like a manual
Heck you could even have a drive by wire clutch
I always thought of that when I drive my wife's 8 speed X3
Great transmission, but it sucks cuz you feel totally disconnected from the shifting
"There are two opinions in this world. Mine and the wrong one." -- Jeremy Clarkson