Originally Posted by beanns
Always call PoPo... Not everyone is as decent as us.
Not only was the OP wrong for not calling the cops (IDC if it was on "private property" property or not, a vehicle accident is an accident and should be reported as such), but he was also wrong for accepting the word of this douchebag offering $750 bucks over the phone. You will probably never see that money.
At this point, it's best to just let your insurance handle it. Give them all the info they need. It'll take a while for this to get fixed though, especially since there's no police report to back up your claim that it was her fault.