Originally Posted by goldminer
I live in Toronto and bought both packages. I got the tire protection because I lost 2 rims on my previous car due to Toronto's crap roads and failure to promptly fill potholes. I just took delivery in July and have already had one tire replaced under warranty due to a screw in it. Replacement was fast, painless and cost nothing.
I got the appearance protection package because it also covers windshields, coverage which my insurance does not have due to a high deductible.
I got the tire protection but do not pay $1500 for it. They definitely have room to give you a discount.
(I also got it due to Toronto's, particularly downtown Toronto's, crap roads, made even crappier because of the 23,425,520 condos being built)