Well, I decided to take it to another shop more fitting for this kinda work and I have to say I'm pleased with the results. Just about everything lines up really well after some trimming, but there are a couple gaps around the headlights that I'm going to have them throw some bondo at to make just about perfect. (Also put some black metal mesh in front of the radiator)
Appreciate all the feedback so far. Was definitely worried about all the people telling me to send it back, but I feel good about this one.. going to have it all fit proper and painted for quite a bit than the real deal.
Once everything is all said and done, I'll write up a review for people looking to go a similar route